Jon Loomer Digital
For Advanced Facebook Marketers
  • Blog
  • Access
    • Building Blocks
    • Membership Info
    • PHC Login
    • Agencies
    • One-on-One
  • FREE
    • The Loop
    • Blog Alerts
    • Video Alerts
    • Cornerstone Tips
    • Podcast Alerts
    • The Full Funnel
    • Beginners
  • Videos
Search
Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors
Search in posts
Search in pages

The smartest Meta advertisers **stay in The Loop!**

Find Out More

Experiment: Status Updates vs. Photos in Facebook Reach

November 5, 2012 by Jon Loomer - 26 Comments

Last updated: March 6, 2025

Share via:

  • Share
  • Post
  • Email
NOTE: This post may be outdated.

Any screenshots and details of functionality may no longer be relevant.

View the most recent posts in this category.

There’s been a LOT of chatter about Facebook Page Reach in general lately. More specifically, there’s been talk of how Reach is down for photos while it’s up for status updates.

Not just a slight change. But a major change to the EdgeRank algorithm.

Is this true? If so, is this simply a cosmetic change? Has engagement been impacted?

My Experiment

For the past several months, I’ve been using photos almost exclusively when sharing my latest blog post every Monday through Friday mornings. I decided to stop last Monday and use only status updates.

I have taken the five photo posts that I made from October 22-26 and compared them to my five status update posts I made from October 29 to November 2.

Note that there are other status updates and photo posts mixed in, but I wanted to compare only the posts that were made to promote a new blog entry. Following are the posts that were used:

10/22 Photo about spam impacting Promoted Posts (Part 1)
10/23 Photo about spam impacting Promoted Posts (Part 2)
10/24 Photo about Fan Page Friday
10/25 Photo about how to merge Facebook Pages
10/26 Photo about Andrea Vahl interview
10/29 Status update about a change in Reach
10/30 Status update about the silent killer of Reach
10/31 Status update about not marketing on Facebook
11/1 Status update about Facebook Page Notifications and Pages Feed
11/2 Status update about Emeric Ernoult interview

Read to the End!


Let me say this now. It’s important that you read everything here. While some of my findings verify what everyone is reporting, there is so much here to understand.

Is Reach up with status updates? Yep. Am I skeptical? Yep. Does it matter? Probably not.

Read on…

Facebook Reach — WHOA!


Everyone claims that Reach is way up for status updates and that photos aren’t being seen by anyone. So let’s look…

Facebook Reach Status Updates Photos

Average Reach for status updates was about 2,400 while it was just under 1,250 for photos. Status updates were reaching an average of 1,635 fans while photos reached only 761. Even when using medians, the difference was close to double.

That’s crazy, right? But it is consistent with everything we’re hearing. Status updates way up, and far outperforming photos.

If you only look at Reach, of course…

Facebook Engagement — Wait, What?


One might assume that if Reach is way higher for status updates that engagement follows. After all, if you can’t reach an audience, they won’t engage.

Quick refresher. Here’s Facebook’s definition of “Engaged User:”

The number of people who clicked anywhere in your posts.

Simple enough, right? So that’s likes, comments, shares, photo clicks and other clicks. Here’s what we’ve got for that same set of data…

Facebook Page Engagement Status Updates Photos

To the naked eye, at least, these appear to be pretty even. Big spike in the beginning for photos, but they average out.

The actual numbers are consistent with the eye test. Let’s use medians for now on to avoid one piece of data that skews the results (as could happen in this set here). I had a median of 89 engaged fans and 134 total engaged users for the photos; it was 96 and 108 for the status updates.

In other words, I was getting virtually the same engagement from fans, but the photos actually got me more engagement from non-fans.

The difference is nothing definitive. But what is clear is that the engagement is very similar even though the Reach was no where close.

But I want more details than clicks anywhere within the posts. You’re probably thinking that photos have an advantage here because of photo clicks. I was thinking the same thing.

So let’s look at a few more sets of data: Likes, Shares, Comments and Other Clicks. And this time, let’s just look at the median scores for each…

Facebook Status Updates Photos Likes Comments Shares Clicks

Huh. So my photos got more likes and shares, comments were the same and status updates got more “other clicks” which resulted in more clicks overall.

By the way, you may be wondering how I found this data. It’s on the “Lifetime Post Consumers by type” tab of the post level export in Facebook Insights.

What Does It All Mean?


If you’ve detected some frustration in my words lately, this kind of stuff is exactly why.

Reach stats don’t tell us anything. This goes back to the very odd Viral Reach stats we’ve seen since the end of August which resulted in a drop in Total Reach. I’ve been tracking my Reach and Engagement closely for months now, and while Reach has become extremely erratic, my Engagement continues to trend upward.

So now that we’re talking about the difference in Reach between post types, I stand firm that this stat means nothing. The proof is the engagement.

I see virtually no difference in engagement between status updates and photos of similar content. That tells me one of two things regarding the Reach numbers, which are double in favor of status updates:

  1. Status updates are getting half of the engagement per user; or
  2. The Reach numbers are wrong.

Either way, I don’t really care. I can’t prove Reach. I can prove engagement. And engagement is what we all care about, right?

Your Turn


The problem, of course, is that I’m only one person. While my individual sample size is enough now to say that I have not been negatively impacted by poor Reach during the past few months, it doesn’t mean that my results apply globally.

So what are you seeing? Your Reach between your status updates and photos are likely quite different. But what about your engagement?

Let me know in the comments below!

Share via:

  • Share
  • Post
  • Email
filed under: Marketing

Tags: Organic Facebook and Instagram

Video Alerts

Video Alerts

The best way to sharpen your Meta advertising skills and knowledge is to subscribe to my short-form videos. I publish a 1-minute video with a short blog post three days per week.

Sign Up Today

PHC

Power Hitters Club
Jon Loomer

BOOST your Meta Advertising Skills

The PHC provides members with access to a private community of advertisers who have done what you’re trying to do, have worked in your industry, and who can pull from valuable experience.

Click here

One-on-One

One-on-One Training

Schedule one-on-one time with Jon to discuss your Facebook advertising struggles, obstacles, and strategies.

Click Here

Podcast Widget

The Pubcast with Jon Loomer

Meta advertising discussions in 5-10 minute “Shots.” A new episode is published every Wednesday on your favorite podcasting platform.

Listen Now

Training: Building Blocks

Training: Building Blocks
Jon Loomer

An introductory and skill-sharpening course on Meta advertising. Improve your campaign creation confidence!

Get Access!

Subscribe to Jon's Blog

Feel like you're always one step behind? Subscribe to Jon's blog for regular Meta advertising tutorials, news, and case studies.

Subscribe

Connect with me:

Tools

  • Facebook Ads FAQ
  • Meta Ads Glossary
  • Facebook Pixel Event Generator
  • Social Media Search Activity
  • Meta’s Earnings Reports
  • Privacy Policy

Services

  • Power Hitters Club
  • One-on-One Consulting
  • Agencies

Quick Links

  • About Me
  • Where Should I Start?
  • The Pubcast
  • Podcast Appearances
  • Blog
  • Where You Can Find Jon
  • Jon’s Advertising Philosophies
  • AI ChatBot
  • Custom Event Mastery
Jon Loomer Digital
For Advanced Facebook Marketers
Email: [email protected]
© 2025 Jon Loomer Digital
Website by Glass Mountains
  • Blog
  • Access
    ▼
    • Building Blocks
    • Membership Info
    • PHC Login
    • Agencies
    • One-on-One
  • FREE
    ▼
    • The Loop
    • Blog Alerts
    • Video Alerts
    • Cornerstone Tips
    • Podcast Alerts
    • The Full Funnel
    • Beginners
  • Videos
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. Is that ok?OkPrivacy Policy