Revenue From Facebook Offers vs. Promoted Posts [Research]

309 Shares Facebook 156 Twitter 78 Buffer 24 Google+ 15 LinkedIn 21 Pin It Share 15 309 Shares ×

[The following is a guest post from Juliette Rule of Sierra Trading Post. Juliette is a client and a brilliant Facebook marketer. Since she controls the Facebook ad spend for a very popular retail brand with nearly 200,000 Facebook fans, Juliette was able to conduct some experiments that provide results on a large scale. I was particularly curious about the revenue generated from Facebook Offers vs. Promoted Posts that drove users to a link to purchase. Here are the eye-opening results.]

Love them or hate them, instinctually, my team knows Facebook ads work to drive sales and engagement, promote reach and garner impressions all while telling a story about our brand.

When Jon asked me to guest post for him and compare our success with two styles of Facebook Ads used by Sierra Trading Post, I nearly leaped at the chance. It was the perfect excuse to open Pandora’s Box of Ad Data and offer some hard facts to a timeline of ad spend.

Background


For two years, I’ve had a dedicated ad budget for Facebook. I’ve learned that sending people away from Facebook to our eCommerce site isn’t effective, but using Sponsored Stories to attract fans and, later, Promoted Posts to enhance engagement with those fans is successful.

When Facebook Offers were unveiled, we gave them a shot, too. Throughout the fourth quarter of this year, we’ve been experimenting with Facebook Offers and Promoted Posts – posts in which we offer a coupon when users click through a shortened link.

Which was more successful for us, Jon wondered. Offers or Promoted Posts?

The Test

To be fair, our test isn’t exactly equal. We did seven Offers and just four Promoted Posts from October through December. Some time frames were longer – they ranged from a coupon being valid just until midnight MST that same day to three days.

sierra trading post facebook offers promoted posts Revenue From Facebook Offers vs. Promoted Posts [Research]
[Editor's Note: Facebook no longer allows advertisers to include purchase information in the imagery of Promoted Posts. However, this study is still valid since a similar ad could be created with the purchase information in the copy.]

Consider, too, that Q4 is an anomaly. People shop more during this time, and the competition is fierce!  All of that skews our results a bit, but there are still learnings in our spreadsheet.

Top Level Observations


Generally, we learned that an Offer or Promoted Post that was valid for three days or so performed much better than those that expired at midnight. Not a shocker, right?

We learned, too, that including the words “Save 30%” in creative attached to a Promoted Post resulted in an ad being approved and then disapproved by Facebook (but it still made money for us, yo!). It would seem that Facebook wants us to use Offers for driving sales, but did the Offer perform favorably?

Bottom line: During our test, we saw an ROAS (Return on Ad Spend) of 210 on Offers – more than 10 times the ROAS on Promoted Posts (we calculated cost of goods sold in our formula, by the way).

ROAS is calculated as follows:

((Paid Impressions/(Paid Impressions+Organic Impressions))*Revenue)/Spend

The result is a ratio, like 210.0. In this example, for every dollar we spent, we made $210.00.

We spent less on those Promoted Posts, saw many fewer impressions but enjoyed a higher CTR of 1.97 percent. For Offers it was just .3 percent.

The Offers outperformed Promoted Posts on revenue, but there were fewer of them and the Promoted Posts were usually valid for just 14 hours.

But here’s a funny observation. In one of my December posts, I created an Offer. Then I missed the opportunity to say I’d like to promote it with ad budget later (it’s a teeny box, but it does allow you to schedule an Offer and ad spend simultaneously). So the post functioned like an Offer, and I wasn’t really sure what to make of the data for that particular post, especially when Facebook called it an Offer in its Page-level download and it represented more than 90 percent of my spend!

It wasn’t a revenue all-star, though it didn’t do too badly. It was the best revenue generator of all the Promoted Posts, bringing in 22 percent of all Promoted Post revenue. I analyzed it as a Promoted Post, but it made me wonder about the distinction Facebook is actually making between the two ad styles. Are they really all that different?

Inconsistent Minimums

It was kind of a rub, actually. In making that mistake, I also realized Facebook jacked its pricing around wildly. The minimum I could spend was, at first, $1,600. An hour later, it was $200. Three hours later $500. That’s when I resolved to keep helping my small-business-owning friends with their low-budget Facebook campaigns.

In all of this, I was freaked out by the ROAS –- they would be considered incredibly successful if we could only decide what was a fair analysis. In the end, we decided to parse out Paid and Organic Impressions (gathered from post-level Insights) and weight the formula.

What We Learned

So, what did we learn in this analysis? We need to keep doing Offers.

ROAS facebook offers promoted posts Revenue From Facebook Offers vs. Promoted Posts [Research]

And we need to keep understanding traditional online marketing techniques for analysis and figuring out where and when it’s appropriate to apply them to social. And we need to look at our ROI so we can tie organic and paid pieces together for social and understand the real effect of ads on our business.

These are all good challenges for 2013, and it’s one my team will be taking on like the ever-learning and always-experimenting pros we are.

Follow Juliette here…

Juliette Rule on Facebook
Sierra Trading Post on Facebook
Sierra Trading Post on Twitter
Sierra Trading Post Blog
Sierra Trading Post on YouTube

 Revenue From Facebook Offers vs. Promoted Posts [Research]

About Juliette Rule

Juliette Rule manages social media and a team of four socializers for Sierra Trading Post, a top 100 Internet retailer based in Cheyenne, Wyo. The brand embraced social fully three years ago, and shares killer contests and deals you wouldn’t believe on Facebook, Twitter and Blog, while handily sharing fabulous how-tos on its YouTube channel as well.

309 Shares Facebook 156 Twitter 78 Buffer 24 Google+ 15 LinkedIn 21 Pin It Share 15 309 Shares ×
  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=5904828 Nina Gannes

    Great addition to this blog for 2013! A question for Juliette – you say promoted posts are best for driving new Likes and engagement with fans. How do you measure the value of that engagement when it doesn’t directly contribute to your bottom line? I LOVED your ROAS formula – do you use something similar for return on engagement vis a vis your revenue?

    • http://www.jkrule.com Juliette Rule

      Thanks, Nina! We’ve found page engagement and fan building to be more successful since the advent of Sponsored Stories, as in we’ve been able to attract more fans and, by extension, enjoyed more engagement. (Those are ever-shifting sands though, as you probably know!) At this point, we’re watching the People Talking About Us number, dividing it by the number of fans to get an idea of the engagement with our Page. It’s not a perfect science, but it’s an easy number to get to. We’re always interested in finding better ways to measure stuff though!

  • Dorien Morin-van Dam

    Great analysis I did a few promoted posts along with a sweepstakes for a (very small business) client, but will surely try out offers for Valentine’s Day! During the December campaigns, the client hit 400 FB fans so the promoted posts could start. Along with the sweepstakes, that really helped. I had not considered offers until I just now read your article! Bookmarked and will be referenced for future projects!

    • http://www.jkrule.com Juliette Rule

      Good luck with Offers, Dorien! You’ll have to pop back into the discussion here or on Jon’s Page and tell us how they did for you! My prediction? You’ll be glad you tried them out!

  • Pingback: Facebook Offers Vs. Promoted Posts TestThe Internet Marketing TV

  • Carlos

    Wow Juliette: You’ve answered the question perfectly and timely too! I love the analysis thank you so much.

  • http://twitter.com/getpeacock Peacock

    If you like Facebook Offers, then try Peacock http://getpeacock.com: a free tool for merchants to bring their Facebook Offers to Twitter. Different from how you normally post offers on Twitter – when users claim your offer via Peacock, they retweet your offer to their followers and help it go viral. No minimum followers required. It’s the fastest and easiest tool for publishing offers on Twitter.

  • Pingback: Facebook Offers: Minimum Requirement Dropped to 100 Likes - JonLoomer.com

  • http://womeninbusinessradio.com Michele Price

    Juliette with Facebook flailing like a two year old having a temper tantrum when it comes to approving ads, can you write a post on what you have found to drive results for you?

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Sam-Taha/1666572074 Sam Taha

    ShopZooky is a fun new way to discover and share local Facebook Offers on your mobile phone. ShopZooky allows shoppers to search for local Facebook Offers from local merchants and manage their saved and claimed Offers from one convenient mobile app. With this latest of ShopZooky, we have enabled tighter integration with Facebook so you can see all the Offers your friends are sharing. No more searching through your email inbox for claimed offers or scanning through your Facebook news feed to see what Offers your friends are sharing.

  • http://www.BlitzMetrics.com Dennis Yu

    Juliette– thanks for sharing. Curious to see how much of the lift was due to virality vs perhaps a lower CPC. We’ve seen that the virality can drive 10X more impressions than paid alone.

    • http://jaronrayhinds.com/ Jaron Ray Hinds

      Being this article was written almost five months ago, there has been many changes in both tactics and distribution channels. I agree with you Dennis, virality on is the only way to fly. A promoted post when done right should harvest similar results to what we are seeing above, but when you supplement that promoted post with a sponsored story, virality drives those penny clicks and ends up with the best EPC. #twocentsworth

309 Shares Facebook 156 Twitter 78 Buffer 24 Google+ 15 LinkedIn 21 Pin It Share 15 309 Shares ×